The Soderbury, Maine Matter: A Town’s Silence, A Rifle’s Truth

Originally Aired: June 2, 1951 In The Soderbury, Maine Matter, insurance investigator Johnny Dollar journeys to a quiet New England town after the murder of Gordon Soderberry, a wealthy industrialist and divisive figure. As Dollar untangles the threads of suspicion, he discovers a community gripped by resentment over a wartime factory’s reopening. The clues point to a local man with a tragic past, but as the investigation deepens, Dollar uncovers a twist—Soderberry wasn’t the intended victim. In a gripping finale, a misguided act of revenge reveals that the true target was an outsider threatening a local man’s pride and place in the town. A tale of legacy, misplaced loyalty, and tragic misfires unfolds in this powerful episode of Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar. Become a supporter of this podcast