Skip to main content
Detectives on the Air artwork

Detectives on the Air

The Valentine Matter Ep 3

Posted July 7, 2026 · 15 min

About this episode

Originally Aired: November 2, 1955 Johnny Dollar #253, "The Valentine Matter Ep 3," Johnny continues his search for Dan Valentine, the former racketeer from the Roaring Twenties who walked out of his hospital bed with two bullets still in him. After confronting Mrs. Valentine at her New Orleans hotel, Johnny presses her for answers about why her husband chose to live so far away from her and their daughter Teresa in New England. She reluctantly reveals that Conrad Webster, a disbarred attorney and old friend of Dan's who handled his insurance policy and daughter's trust, might be living in the city. Johnny wonders if the injured man sought refuge with this connection from his past. Following a trail through bars and flophouses, Johnny tracks Webster down at three in the morning to a rundown duplex on Gentilly Street. He finds a drunk, philosophical old man who speaks bitterly about their vanished era of Hamburg hats and the Charleston. Webster insists he hasn't seen Dan and doesn't know his whereabouts, though he reveals a deep melancholy about their faded generation. As Johnny leaves empty-handed, the mystery of Dan Valentine's disappearance deepens, with time running out for the bleeding fugitive somewhere in the New Orleans night. Become a supporter of this podcast

From Detectives on the Air by OTR.FM Network. Visit the show’s website.

More from Detectives on the Air

All episodes