Skip to main content
Gunsmoke: Old West Stories artwork

Gunsmoke: Old West Stories

Annie Oakley: A Rifle, a Lie, and a Woman’s Desperation

Posted September 1, 2025 · 21 min

About this episode

Originally Aired: August 19, 1956 In Gunsmoke #228, “Annie Oakley,” a bitter love triangle erupts into murder on the plains near Dodge. When Kate Kinsman’s husband is shot dead with a Sharps rifle, all signs point to Ed Dolliver, the man she accused of pursuing her. But Marshal Dillon isn’t convinced by appearances—or by Kate’s tearful accusations. As a trap is laid with a note, a decoy, and a deadly shot from over a thousand yards, the truth about Kate’s past and her desperate hunger for attention is revealed. A chilling portrait of manipulation and misplaced pride on the American frontier. Cast: Jeanette Nolan, Harry Bartell, Paul Duval, Parley Baer, Howard McNear, Georgia Ellis Tags: Western, murder, sharpshooter, manipulation, Gunsmoke, 1950sradio, oldtimeradio, DodgeCity, jealousy, classicdrama, femmefatale, annieoakley, justice, psychological, suspensepodcast

From Gunsmoke: Old West Stories by OTR.FM Network. Visit the show’s website.

More from Gunsmoke: Old West Stories

All episodes